Replacing Mercury Fillings in Albany: What a SMART Removal Visit Looks Like, and What Goes in Their Place
Mercury filling removal is the process of taking out old silver (amalgam) fillings and replacing them with tooth-colored, metal-free materials. When it’s done under the SMART protocol, additional measures such as rubber dam isolation, high-volume suction, air filtration, and supplemental oxygen are used to limit mercury vapor exposure for the patient and the dental team.
Do those silver fillings you’ve had since childhood need to come out? It’s one of the most common questions we hear at Dental Wellness of Albany, and it usually comes from someone who has read a lot online and is trying to separate the useful information from the noise.
Some people are motivated by appearance: they’re tired of seeing dark spots when they laugh. Others have cracked teeth around old fillings. Many come to our Delaware Avenue office because they want a mouth that’s as metal-free as possible, and they want the removal done carefully.
All of those are valid reasons. What matters is making the decision with good information and choosing a dentist who removes amalgam in a way that doesn’t create a bigger exposure than leaving it alone.
The goal isn’t to rush every filling out tomorrow. It’s to make a clear plan you feel good about.
Should You Replace Silver Fillings That Aren’t Bothering You?
Amalgam fillings are roughly half mercury by weight, bound with silver, tin, and copper. They release small amounts of mercury vapor over time, especially when you chew, grind, or drink hot liquids.
Here’s where the major organizations stand:
- The FDA (2020) recommends that certain higher-risk groups avoid getting new amalgam fillings when appropriate. That includes people who are pregnant, nursing, or planning a pregnancy, children under six, and people with certain neurological conditions, impaired kidney function, or a known mercury sensitivity. The FDA does not recommend removing amalgam fillings that are in good condition unless there’s a medical reason, because removal itself can release mercury vapor.
- The International Academy of Oral Medicine and Toxicology (IAOMT) takes a more cautious view of mercury in dentistry. It developed the Safe Mercury Amalgam Removal Technique (SMART) to keep exposure as low as possible when fillings do come out.
So “should I replace them?” really becomes “should I replace them, and if so, how?” Good reasons to consider replacement include:
- A filling that’s cracked, leaking, or has decay underneath
- A tooth that’s fractured around a large, old filling
- A strong personal preference for metal-free dentistry
- Cosmetic concerns about dark fillings that show when you smile
If you’d like more background on the science, our earlier article on what we now know about mercury fillings covers it in more depth.
What SMART Certification Means at Dental Wellness of Albany
Dr. Robert Herzog is a certified SMART dentist and a member of the IAOMT. He is also Board Certified in Integrative Biologic Dental Medicine and brings more than 30 years of clinical experience to every removal.
SMART certification means he has trained in and follows a specific set of safeguards. It isn’t a marketing label. It changes how the room is set up, what the patient wears, and how the filling is removed. You can read the full list of safeguards on our safe mercury amalgam removal page, and our May article explains the SMART protocol step by step.
Your Removal Visit, Step by Step
Knowing what will happen takes a lot of the worry out of the appointment. Here’s how a typical visit flows:
- Room preparation. High-volume air filtration and an aerosol vacuum are running before you sit down, and the office has amalgam separators to keep mercury out of the wastewater.
- Protection for you. You’ll rinse with an adsorbent slurry, then you’re covered with a full-body drape and head covering. Supplemental oxygen is delivered through a nasal mask so you aren’t breathing room air near your mouth.
- Isolation. A nitrile rubber dam (a thin sheet that seals around the tooth) keeps particles away from your throat and the rest of your mouth.
- Sectioning, not grinding. Instead of drilling the filling into fine dust, the dentist cuts it into large chunks with a small carbide bur and lifts them out. Plenty of cool water keeps heat down, since heat increases vapor.
- High-volume evacuation. Suction sits right at the tooth the entire time to capture particles and vapor.
- Clean-up. The dam is removed, and your mouth is rinsed thoroughly with water, then with another adsorbent rinse.
- Restoration. The tooth is cleaned, and the new metal-free material is placed.
The dental team also wears protective gowns, face shields, and respiratory-grade masks. That protects them, and it’s a good sign the office takes the process seriously.
What Replaces the Amalgam?
Once the old filling is removed, the right replacement depends on how much healthy tooth remains. Dr. Herzog will recommend an option after he sees the tooth, but here’s how the common choices compare:
| Situation | Common replacement | Metal-free? | Look | Typical visits |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Small to moderate filling, strong walls left | Tooth-colored composite resin (a “white filling”) | Yes | Matches your natural shade | Usually one |
| Larger filling, some weakened tooth structure | Ceramic inlay or onlay (a custom piece that fits into or over part of the tooth) | Yes | Very natural, stain-resistant | Often two |
| Cracked tooth or very large old filling | Full-coverage ceramic or zirconia crown | Yes | Natural, highly durable | Usually two |
For many patients, the answer is composite. Modern white fillings bond directly to the tooth, which means less healthy structure has to be removed than with amalgam.
How Many Fillings at Once? Sequencing and Pacing
If you have several amalgam fillings, you don’t have to replace them all in one sitting. Many patients prefer to work in stages, one quadrant (a quarter of the mouth) at a time.
Pacing the work gives you time to rest between visits and allows the plan to align with your budget and insurance year. It also allows Dr. Herzog to put the most urgent teeth first, such as cracked or decayed ones, before moving on to elective replacements.
Amalgam vs. Composite at a Glance
- Material: Amalgam is a metal alloy with mercury. Composite is a tooth-colored resin with glass-like filler particles.
- Appearance: Amalgam is silver and darkens over time. Composite blends with your tooth.
- Tooth preparation: Amalgam needs undercuts to lock in place. Composite bonds to the tooth, so more of the natural structure can be preserved.
- Expansion: Amalgam expands and contracts with temperature, which can contribute to cracks over decades. Composite doesn’t stress the tooth the same way.
- Lifespan: Both can last many years with good care. Large composite fillings in heavy-chewing areas may need replacement sooner, at which point an onlay or crown may be the better choice.
Common Questions About Mercury Filling Removal
Can I have amalgam fillings removed while pregnant or breastfeeding? Elective amalgam removal is generally postponed during pregnancy and while nursing. Removal can briefly increase mercury exposure, even with safeguards in place. If a filling is broken or painful, Dr. Herzog will discuss the safest short-term way to protect the tooth until you’re ready for a full replacement.
Does insurance cover replacing silver fillings? Coverage depends on your plan and the reason for replacement. A cracked or decayed filling is usually considered a necessary restoration, whereas a purely elective replacement may not be covered. Some plans pay for back-tooth composites at the amalgam rate, and our team can help you check your benefits before treatment.
Will my teeth be sensitive afterward? Some patients notice mild sensitivity to cold or biting pressure for a few days. That’s common after any new filling and usually fades on its own. Let us know if it lingers, because a small bite adjustment often helps.
How long do white fillings last? With good home care and regular checkups, composite fillings commonly last many years. Their lifespan depends on the size of the filling, where it is in your mouth, and habits like grinding. Wearing a nightguard if you clench can help protect them.
Schedule Your Mercury Filling Consultation in Albany
If you’ve been wondering whether your silver fillings should come out, the first step is a conversation, not a commitment. Dr. Herzog will examine each filling, explain which ones need attention now and which can wait, and map out a SMART-protocol plan that fits your health goals. Request an appointment online or call 518-427-2447. Our office at 651 Delaware Avenue is an easy drive from Delmar and Glenmont.






